Analysis of 111/999 NHS calls and 111 online reports
Quentin Leclerc, Emily Nightingale, Samuel Abbott & Thibaut Jombart, for CMMID
Friday 14 August 2020
1 Data preparation
1.1 Outline
Load scripts: loads libraries and useful scripts used in the analyses; all
.Rfiles contained inscriptsat the root of the factory are automatically loadedLoad data: imports datasets, and may contain some ad hoc changes to the data such as specific data cleaning (not used in other reports), new variables used in the analyses, etc.
1.2 Load packages
library(reportfactory)
library(here)
library(rio)
library(tidyverse)
library(incidence)
library(distcrete)
library(epitrix)
library(earlyR)
library(projections)
library(linelist)
library(remotes)
library(janitor)
library(kableExtra)
library(DT)
library(cyphr)
library(chngpt)
library(lubridate)
library(ggpubr)
library(ggnewscale)1.3 Load scripts
These scripts will load:
- all scripts stored as
.Rfiles inside/scripts/ - all scripts stored as
.Rfiles inside/src/
These scripts also contain routines to access the latest clean encrypted data (see next section).
1.4 Load clean data
We import the latest NHS pathways data:
x <- import_pathways() %>%
as_tibble()
x
## [90m# A tibble: 207,216 x 11[39m
## site_type date sex age ccg_code ccg_name count postcode nhs_region
## [3m[90m<chr>[39m[23m [3m[90m<date>[39m[23m [3m[90m<chr>[39m[23m [3m[90m<chr>[39m[23m [3m[90m<chr>[39m[23m [3m[90m<chr>[39m[23m [3m[90m<int>[39m[23m [3m[90m<chr>[39m[23m [3m[90m<chr>[39m[23m
## [90m 1[39m 111 2020-03-18 fema… miss… e380000… nhs_glo… 1 gl34fe South West
## [90m 2[39m 111 2020-03-18 fema… miss… e380001… nhs_sou… 1 ne325nn North Eas…
## [90m 3[39m 111 2020-03-18 fema… 0-18 e380000… nhs_air… 8 bd57jr North Eas…
## [90m 4[39m 111 2020-03-18 fema… 0-18 e380000… nhs_ash… 7 tn254ab South East
## [90m 5[39m 111 2020-03-18 fema… 0-18 e380000… nhs_bar… 35 rm13ae London
## [90m 6[39m 111 2020-03-18 fema… 0-18 e380000… nhs_bar… 9 n111np London
## [90m 7[39m 111 2020-03-18 fema… 0-18 e380000… nhs_bar… 11 s752py North Eas…
## [90m 8[39m 111 2020-03-18 fema… 0-18 e380000… nhs_bas… 19 ss143hg East of E…
## [90m 9[39m 111 2020-03-18 fema… 0-18 e380000… nhs_bas… 6 dn227xf North Eas…
## [90m10[39m 111 2020-03-18 fema… 0-18 e380000… nhs_bat… 9 ba25rp South West
## [90m# … with 207,206 more rows, and 2 more variables: day [3m[90m<int>[90m[23m, weekday [3m[90m<fct>[90m[23m[39mWe also import demographics data for NHS regions in England, used later in our analysis:
path <- here::here("data", "csv", "nhs_region_population_2018.csv")
nhs_region_pop <- rio::import(path) %>%
mutate(nhs_region = str_to_title(gsub("_"," ",nhs_region)))
nhs_region_pop$nhs_region <- gsub(" Of ", " of ", nhs_region_pop$nhs_region)
nhs_region_pop$nhs_region <- gsub(" And ", " and ", nhs_region_pop$nhs_region)
nhs_region_pop
## nhs_region variable value
## 1 North West 0-18 0.22538599
## 2 North East and Yorkshire 0-18 0.21876449
## 3 Midlands 0-18 0.22564656
## 4 East of England 0-18 0.22810783
## 5 London 0-18 0.23764782
## 6 South East 0-18 0.22458811
## 7 South West 0-18 0.20799797
## 8 North West 19-69 0.64274078
## 9 North East and Yorkshire 19-69 0.64437753
## 10 Midlands 19-69 0.63876675
## 11 East of England 19-69 0.63034229
## 12 London 19-69 0.67820084
## 13 South East 19-69 0.63267336
## 14 South West 19-69 0.63176131
## 15 North West 70-120 0.13187323
## 16 North East and Yorkshire 70-120 0.13685797
## 17 Midlands 70-120 0.13558669
## 18 East of England 70-120 0.14154988
## 19 London 70-120 0.08415135
## 20 South East 70-120 0.14273853
## 21 South West 70-120 0.16024072Finally, we import publically available deaths per NHS region:
dth <- import_deaths() %>%
mutate(nhs_region = str_to_title(gsub("_"," ",nhs_region)))
#truncation to account for reporting delay
delay_max <- 21
dth$nhs_region <- gsub(" Of ", " of ", dth$nhs_region)
dth$nhs_region <- gsub(" And ", " and ", dth$nhs_region)
dth
## date_report nhs_region deaths
## 1 2020-03-01 East of England 0
## 2 2020-03-02 East of England 1
## 3 2020-03-03 East of England 0
## 4 2020-03-04 East of England 0
## 5 2020-03-05 East of England 0
## 6 2020-03-06 East of England 1
## 7 2020-03-07 East of England 0
## 8 2020-03-08 East of England 0
## 9 2020-03-09 East of England 1
## 10 2020-03-10 East of England 0
## 11 2020-03-11 East of England 0
## 12 2020-03-12 East of England 0
## 13 2020-03-13 East of England 1
## 14 2020-03-14 East of England 2
## 15 2020-03-15 East of England 2
## 16 2020-03-16 East of England 1
## 17 2020-03-17 East of England 1
## 18 2020-03-18 East of England 5
## 19 2020-03-19 East of England 4
## 20 2020-03-20 East of England 2
## 21 2020-03-21 East of England 11
## 22 2020-03-22 East of England 12
## 23 2020-03-23 East of England 11
## 24 2020-03-24 East of England 19
## 25 2020-03-25 East of England 26
## 26 2020-03-26 East of England 36
## 27 2020-03-27 East of England 38
## 28 2020-03-28 East of England 28
## 29 2020-03-29 East of England 43
## 30 2020-03-30 East of England 45
## 31 2020-03-31 East of England 70
## 32 2020-04-01 East of England 62
## 33 2020-04-02 East of England 65
## 34 2020-04-03 East of England 80
## 35 2020-04-04 East of England 71
## 36 2020-04-05 East of England 76
## 37 2020-04-06 East of England 71
## 38 2020-04-07 East of England 93
## 39 2020-04-08 East of England 111
## 40 2020-04-09 East of England 87
## 41 2020-04-10 East of England 74
## 42 2020-04-11 East of England 92
## 43 2020-04-12 East of England 100
## 44 2020-04-13 East of England 78
## 45 2020-04-14 East of England 61
## 46 2020-04-15 East of England 82
## 47 2020-04-16 East of England 74
## 48 2020-04-17 East of England 86
## 49 2020-04-18 East of England 64
## 50 2020-04-19 East of England 67
## 51 2020-04-20 East of England 67
## 52 2020-04-21 East of England 75
## 53 2020-04-22 East of England 67
## 54 2020-04-23 East of England 49
## 55 2020-04-24 East of England 66
## 56 2020-04-25 East of England 54
## 57 2020-04-26 East of England 48
## 58 2020-04-27 East of England 46
## 59 2020-04-28 East of England 58
## 60 2020-04-29 East of England 32
## 61 2020-04-30 East of England 45
## 62 2020-05-01 East of England 49
## 63 2020-05-02 East of England 29
## 64 2020-05-03 East of England 41
## 65 2020-05-04 East of England 19
## 66 2020-05-05 East of England 36
## 67 2020-05-06 East of England 31
## 68 2020-05-07 East of England 33
## 69 2020-05-08 East of England 33
## 70 2020-05-09 East of England 29
## 71 2020-05-10 East of England 22
## 72 2020-05-11 East of England 18
## 73 2020-05-12 East of England 21
## 74 2020-05-13 East of England 27
## 75 2020-05-14 East of England 26
## 76 2020-05-15 East of England 19
## 77 2020-05-16 East of England 26
## 78 2020-05-17 East of England 17
## 79 2020-05-18 East of England 25
## 80 2020-05-19 East of England 15
## 81 2020-05-20 East of England 26
## 82 2020-05-21 East of England 21
## 83 2020-05-22 East of England 13
## 84 2020-05-23 East of England 12
## 85 2020-05-24 East of England 17
## 86 2020-05-25 East of England 25
## 87 2020-05-26 East of England 14
## 88 2020-05-27 East of England 12
## 89 2020-05-28 East of England 17
## 90 2020-05-29 East of England 16
## 91 2020-05-30 East of England 9
## 92 2020-05-31 East of England 8
## 93 2020-06-01 East of England 17
## 94 2020-06-02 East of England 14
## 95 2020-06-03 East of England 10
## 96 2020-06-04 East of England 7
## 97 2020-06-05 East of England 14
## 98 2020-06-06 East of England 5
## 99 2020-06-07 East of England 9
## 100 2020-06-08 East of England 7
## 101 2020-06-09 East of England 6
## 102 2020-06-10 East of England 8
## 103 2020-06-11 East of England 1
## 104 2020-06-12 East of England 9
## 105 2020-06-13 East of England 5
## 106 2020-06-14 East of England 4
## 107 2020-06-15 East of England 8
## 108 2020-06-16 East of England 3
## 109 2020-06-17 East of England 7
## 110 2020-06-18 East of England 4
## 111 2020-06-19 East of England 7
## 112 2020-06-20 East of England 4
## 113 2020-06-21 East of England 3
## 114 2020-06-22 East of England 6
## 115 2020-06-23 East of England 5
## 116 2020-06-24 East of England 4
## 117 2020-06-25 East of England 1
## 118 2020-06-26 East of England 5
## 119 2020-06-27 East of England 6
## 120 2020-06-28 East of England 8
## 121 2020-06-29 East of England 4
## 122 2020-06-30 East of England 5
## 123 2020-07-01 East of England 2
## 124 2020-07-02 East of England 5
## 125 2020-07-03 East of England 0
## 126 2020-07-04 East of England 3
## 127 2020-07-05 East of England 1
## 128 2020-07-06 East of England 2
## 129 2020-07-07 East of England 2
## 130 2020-07-08 East of England 0
## 131 2020-07-09 East of England 8
## 132 2020-07-10 East of England 4
## 133 2020-07-11 East of England 2
## 134 2020-07-12 East of England 1
## 135 2020-07-13 East of England 7
## 136 2020-07-14 East of England 2
## 137 2020-07-15 East of England 0
## 138 2020-07-16 East of England 0
## 139 2020-07-17 East of England 0
## 140 2020-07-18 East of England 0
## 141 2020-07-19 East of England 1
## 142 2020-07-20 East of England 1
## 143 2020-07-21 East of England 1
## 144 2020-07-22 East of England 1
## 145 2020-07-23 East of England 1
## 146 2020-07-24 East of England 1
## 147 2020-07-25 East of England 0
## 148 2020-07-26 East of England 1
## 149 2020-07-27 East of England 1
## 150 2020-07-28 East of England 1
## 151 2020-07-29 East of England 0
## 152 2020-07-30 East of England 0
## 153 2020-07-31 East of England 1
## 154 2020-08-01 East of England 0
## 155 2020-08-02 East of England 0
## 156 2020-08-03 East of England 0
## 157 2020-08-04 East of England 1
## 158 2020-08-05 East of England 1
## 159 2020-08-06 East of England 0
## 160 2020-08-07 East of England 1
## 161 2020-08-08 East of England 0
## 162 2020-08-09 East of England 0
## 163 2020-08-10 East of England 0
## 164 2020-08-11 East of England 0
## 165 2020-08-12 East of England 0
## 166 2020-03-01 London 0
## 167 2020-03-02 London 0
## 168 2020-03-03 London 0
## 169 2020-03-04 London 0
## 170 2020-03-05 London 0
## 171 2020-03-06 London 1
## 172 2020-03-07 London 0
## 173 2020-03-08 London 0
## 174 2020-03-09 London 1
## 175 2020-03-10 London 0
## 176 2020-03-11 London 5
## 177 2020-03-12 London 6
## 178 2020-03-13 London 10
## 179 2020-03-14 London 13
## 180 2020-03-15 London 9
## 181 2020-03-16 London 15
## 182 2020-03-17 London 23
## 183 2020-03-18 London 27
## 184 2020-03-19 London 25
## 185 2020-03-20 London 44
## 186 2020-03-21 London 49
## 187 2020-03-22 London 54
## 188 2020-03-23 London 63
## 189 2020-03-24 London 86
## 190 2020-03-25 London 112
## 191 2020-03-26 London 129
## 192 2020-03-27 London 129
## 193 2020-03-28 London 122
## 194 2020-03-29 London 145
## 195 2020-03-30 London 149
## 196 2020-03-31 London 181
## 197 2020-04-01 London 202
## 198 2020-04-02 London 191
## 199 2020-04-03 London 197
## 200 2020-04-04 London 231
## 201 2020-04-05 London 195
## 202 2020-04-06 London 197
## 203 2020-04-07 London 220
## 204 2020-04-08 London 239
## 205 2020-04-09 London 206
## 206 2020-04-10 London 171
## 207 2020-04-11 London 178
## 208 2020-04-12 London 158
## 209 2020-04-13 London 166
## 210 2020-04-14 London 143
## 211 2020-04-15 London 142
## 212 2020-04-16 London 140
## 213 2020-04-17 London 100
## 214 2020-04-18 London 101
## 215 2020-04-19 London 103
## 216 2020-04-20 London 96
## 217 2020-04-21 London 94
## 218 2020-04-22 London 109
## 219 2020-04-23 London 77
## 220 2020-04-24 London 71
## 221 2020-04-25 London 58
## 222 2020-04-26 London 53
## 223 2020-04-27 London 51
## 224 2020-04-28 London 44
## 225 2020-04-29 London 45
## 226 2020-04-30 London 40
## 227 2020-05-01 London 41
## 228 2020-05-02 London 41
## 229 2020-05-03 London 36
## 230 2020-05-04 London 30
## 231 2020-05-05 London 25
## 232 2020-05-06 London 37
## 233 2020-05-07 London 37
## 234 2020-05-08 London 30
## 235 2020-05-09 London 23
## 236 2020-05-10 London 26
## 237 2020-05-11 London 18
## 238 2020-05-12 London 18
## 239 2020-05-13 London 17
## 240 2020-05-14 London 20
## 241 2020-05-15 London 18
## 242 2020-05-16 London 14
## 243 2020-05-17 London 15
## 244 2020-05-18 London 11
## 245 2020-05-19 London 14
## 246 2020-05-20 London 19
## 247 2020-05-21 London 12
## 248 2020-05-22 London 10
## 249 2020-05-23 London 6
## 250 2020-05-24 London 7
## 251 2020-05-25 London 9
## 252 2020-05-26 London 14
## 253 2020-05-27 London 7
## 254 2020-05-28 London 8
## 255 2020-05-29 London 7
## 256 2020-05-30 London 12
## 257 2020-05-31 London 6
## 258 2020-06-01 London 10
## 259 2020-06-02 London 8
## 260 2020-06-03 London 6
## 261 2020-06-04 London 8
## 262 2020-06-05 London 4
## 263 2020-06-06 London 0
## 264 2020-06-07 London 5
## 265 2020-06-08 London 5
## 266 2020-06-09 London 5
## 267 2020-06-10 London 8
## 268 2020-06-11 London 5
## 269 2020-06-12 London 3
## 270 2020-06-13 London 3
## 271 2020-06-14 London 3
## 272 2020-06-15 London 1
## 273 2020-06-16 London 2
## 274 2020-06-17 London 1
## 275 2020-06-18 London 2
## 276 2020-06-19 London 5
## 277 2020-06-20 London 3
## 278 2020-06-21 London 4
## 279 2020-06-22 London 2
## 280 2020-06-23 London 1
## 281 2020-06-24 London 4
## 282 2020-06-25 London 3
## 283 2020-06-26 London 2
## 284 2020-06-27 London 1
## 285 2020-06-28 London 2
## 286 2020-06-29 London 2
## 287 2020-06-30 London 1
## 288 2020-07-01 London 2
## 289 2020-07-02 London 2
## 290 2020-07-03 London 2
## 291 2020-07-04 London 1
## 292 2020-07-05 London 3
## 293 2020-07-06 London 2
## 294 2020-07-07 London 1
## 295 2020-07-08 London 3
## 296 2020-07-09 London 4
## 297 2020-07-10 London 0
## 298 2020-07-11 London 1
## 299 2020-07-12 London 1
## 300 2020-07-13 London 1
## 301 2020-07-14 London 0
## 302 2020-07-15 London 2
## 303 2020-07-16 London 0
## 304 2020-07-17 London 0
## 305 2020-07-18 London 2
## 306 2020-07-19 London 0
## 307 2020-07-20 London 0
## 308 2020-07-21 London 1
## 309 2020-07-22 London 0
## 310 2020-07-23 London 2
## 311 2020-07-24 London 0
## 312 2020-07-25 London 1
## 313 2020-07-26 London 0
## 314 2020-07-27 London 1
## 315 2020-07-28 London 0
## 316 2020-07-29 London 0
## 317 2020-07-30 London 0
## 318 2020-07-31 London 0
## 319 2020-08-01 London 0
## 320 2020-08-02 London 2
## 321 2020-08-03 London 0
## 322 2020-08-04 London 0
## 323 2020-08-05 London 0
## 324 2020-08-06 London 1
## 325 2020-08-07 London 0
## 326 2020-08-08 London 0
## 327 2020-08-09 London 0
## 328 2020-08-10 London 0
## 329 2020-08-11 London 1
## 330 2020-08-12 London 0
## 331 2020-03-01 Midlands 0
## 332 2020-03-02 Midlands 0
## 333 2020-03-03 Midlands 1
## 334 2020-03-04 Midlands 0
## 335 2020-03-05 Midlands 0
## 336 2020-03-06 Midlands 0
## 337 2020-03-07 Midlands 0
## 338 2020-03-08 Midlands 2
## 339 2020-03-09 Midlands 1
## 340 2020-03-10 Midlands 0
## 341 2020-03-11 Midlands 2
## 342 2020-03-12 Midlands 6
## 343 2020-03-13 Midlands 5
## 344 2020-03-14 Midlands 4
## 345 2020-03-15 Midlands 5
## 346 2020-03-16 Midlands 11
## 347 2020-03-17 Midlands 8
## 348 2020-03-18 Midlands 13
## 349 2020-03-19 Midlands 8
## 350 2020-03-20 Midlands 28
## 351 2020-03-21 Midlands 13
## 352 2020-03-22 Midlands 31
## 353 2020-03-23 Midlands 33
## 354 2020-03-24 Midlands 41
## 355 2020-03-25 Midlands 48
## 356 2020-03-26 Midlands 64
## 357 2020-03-27 Midlands 72
## 358 2020-03-28 Midlands 89
## 359 2020-03-29 Midlands 92
## 360 2020-03-30 Midlands 90
## 361 2020-03-31 Midlands 123
## 362 2020-04-01 Midlands 140
## 363 2020-04-02 Midlands 142
## 364 2020-04-03 Midlands 124
## 365 2020-04-04 Midlands 151
## 366 2020-04-05 Midlands 164
## 367 2020-04-06 Midlands 140
## 368 2020-04-07 Midlands 123
## 369 2020-04-08 Midlands 186
## 370 2020-04-09 Midlands 139
## 371 2020-04-10 Midlands 127
## 372 2020-04-11 Midlands 142
## 373 2020-04-12 Midlands 139
## 374 2020-04-13 Midlands 120
## 375 2020-04-14 Midlands 116
## 376 2020-04-15 Midlands 147
## 377 2020-04-16 Midlands 102
## 378 2020-04-17 Midlands 118
## 379 2020-04-18 Midlands 115
## 380 2020-04-19 Midlands 92
## 381 2020-04-20 Midlands 107
## 382 2020-04-21 Midlands 86
## 383 2020-04-22 Midlands 78
## 384 2020-04-23 Midlands 103
## 385 2020-04-24 Midlands 79
## 386 2020-04-25 Midlands 72
## 387 2020-04-26 Midlands 81
## 388 2020-04-27 Midlands 74
## 389 2020-04-28 Midlands 68
## 390 2020-04-29 Midlands 53
## 391 2020-04-30 Midlands 56
## 392 2020-05-01 Midlands 64
## 393 2020-05-02 Midlands 51
## 394 2020-05-03 Midlands 52
## 395 2020-05-04 Midlands 61
## 396 2020-05-05 Midlands 59
## 397 2020-05-06 Midlands 59
## 398 2020-05-07 Midlands 48
## 399 2020-05-08 Midlands 34
## 400 2020-05-09 Midlands 37
## 401 2020-05-10 Midlands 42
## 402 2020-05-11 Midlands 33
## 403 2020-05-12 Midlands 45
## 404 2020-05-13 Midlands 40
## 405 2020-05-14 Midlands 38
## 406 2020-05-15 Midlands 40
## 407 2020-05-16 Midlands 34
## 408 2020-05-17 Midlands 31
## 409 2020-05-18 Midlands 36
## 410 2020-05-19 Midlands 35
## 411 2020-05-20 Midlands 36
## 412 2020-05-21 Midlands 32
## 413 2020-05-22 Midlands 27
## 414 2020-05-23 Midlands 34
## 415 2020-05-24 Midlands 20
## 416 2020-05-25 Midlands 26
## 417 2020-05-26 Midlands 33
## 418 2020-05-27 Midlands 29
## 419 2020-05-28 Midlands 28
## 420 2020-05-29 Midlands 20
## 421 2020-05-30 Midlands 21
## 422 2020-05-31 Midlands 22
## 423 2020-06-01 Midlands 20
## 424 2020-06-02 Midlands 22
## 425 2020-06-03 Midlands 24
## 426 2020-06-04 Midlands 16
## 427 2020-06-05 Midlands 21
## 428 2020-06-06 Midlands 20
## 429 2020-06-07 Midlands 17
## 430 2020-06-08 Midlands 16
## 431 2020-06-09 Midlands 18
## 432 2020-06-10 Midlands 15
## 433 2020-06-11 Midlands 13
## 434 2020-06-12 Midlands 12
## 435 2020-06-13 Midlands 6
## 436 2020-06-14 Midlands 18
## 437 2020-06-15 Midlands 12
## 438 2020-06-16 Midlands 15
## 439 2020-06-17 Midlands 11
## 440 2020-06-18 Midlands 15
## 441 2020-06-19 Midlands 10
## 442 2020-06-20 Midlands 15
## 443 2020-06-21 Midlands 14
## 444 2020-06-22 Midlands 14
## 445 2020-06-23 Midlands 16
## 446 2020-06-24 Midlands 15
## 447 2020-06-25 Midlands 18
## 448 2020-06-26 Midlands 5
## 449 2020-06-27 Midlands 5
## 450 2020-06-28 Midlands 7
## 451 2020-06-29 Midlands 6
## 452 2020-06-30 Midlands 6
## 453 2020-07-01 Midlands 7
## 454 2020-07-02 Midlands 10
## 455 2020-07-03 Midlands 3
## 456 2020-07-04 Midlands 4
## 457 2020-07-05 Midlands 6
## 458 2020-07-06 Midlands 5
## 459 2020-07-07 Midlands 3
## 460 2020-07-08 Midlands 5
## 461 2020-07-09 Midlands 9
## 462 2020-07-10 Midlands 3
## 463 2020-07-11 Midlands 0
## 464 2020-07-12 Midlands 5
## 465 2020-07-13 Midlands 1
## 466 2020-07-14 Midlands 1
## 467 2020-07-15 Midlands 6
## 468 2020-07-16 Midlands 2
## 469 2020-07-17 Midlands 3
## 470 2020-07-18 Midlands 3
## 471 2020-07-19 Midlands 3
## 472 2020-07-20 Midlands 3
## 473 2020-07-21 Midlands 1
## 474 2020-07-22 Midlands 2
## 475 2020-07-23 Midlands 6
## 476 2020-07-24 Midlands 1
## 477 2020-07-25 Midlands 4
## 478 2020-07-26 Midlands 4
## 479 2020-07-27 Midlands 5
## 480 2020-07-28 Midlands 1
## 481 2020-07-29 Midlands 1
## 482 2020-07-30 Midlands 1
## 483 2020-07-31 Midlands 1
## 484 2020-08-01 Midlands 0
## 485 2020-08-02 Midlands 2
## 486 2020-08-03 Midlands 2
## 487 2020-08-04 Midlands 1
## 488 2020-08-05 Midlands 1
## 489 2020-08-06 Midlands 0
## 490 2020-08-07 Midlands 3
## 491 2020-08-08 Midlands 1
## 492 2020-08-09 Midlands 0
## 493 2020-08-10 Midlands 0
## 494 2020-08-11 Midlands 1
## 495 2020-08-12 Midlands 0
## 496 2020-03-01 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 497 2020-03-02 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 498 2020-03-03 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 499 2020-03-04 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 500 2020-03-05 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 501 2020-03-06 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 502 2020-03-07 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 503 2020-03-08 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 504 2020-03-09 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 505 2020-03-10 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 506 2020-03-11 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 507 2020-03-12 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 508 2020-03-13 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 509 2020-03-14 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 510 2020-03-15 North East and Yorkshire 2
## 511 2020-03-16 North East and Yorkshire 3
## 512 2020-03-17 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 513 2020-03-18 North East and Yorkshire 2
## 514 2020-03-19 North East and Yorkshire 6
## 515 2020-03-20 North East and Yorkshire 5
## 516 2020-03-21 North East and Yorkshire 6
## 517 2020-03-22 North East and Yorkshire 7
## 518 2020-03-23 North East and Yorkshire 9
## 519 2020-03-24 North East and Yorkshire 8
## 520 2020-03-25 North East and Yorkshire 18
## 521 2020-03-26 North East and Yorkshire 21
## 522 2020-03-27 North East and Yorkshire 28
## 523 2020-03-28 North East and Yorkshire 35
## 524 2020-03-29 North East and Yorkshire 38
## 525 2020-03-30 North East and Yorkshire 64
## 526 2020-03-31 North East and Yorkshire 60
## 527 2020-04-01 North East and Yorkshire 67
## 528 2020-04-02 North East and Yorkshire 75
## 529 2020-04-03 North East and Yorkshire 100
## 530 2020-04-04 North East and Yorkshire 105
## 531 2020-04-05 North East and Yorkshire 92
## 532 2020-04-06 North East and Yorkshire 96
## 533 2020-04-07 North East and Yorkshire 102
## 534 2020-04-08 North East and Yorkshire 107
## 535 2020-04-09 North East and Yorkshire 111
## 536 2020-04-10 North East and Yorkshire 117
## 537 2020-04-11 North East and Yorkshire 98
## 538 2020-04-12 North East and Yorkshire 84
## 539 2020-04-13 North East and Yorkshire 94
## 540 2020-04-14 North East and Yorkshire 107
## 541 2020-04-15 North East and Yorkshire 96
## 542 2020-04-16 North East and Yorkshire 103
## 543 2020-04-17 North East and Yorkshire 88
## 544 2020-04-18 North East and Yorkshire 95
## 545 2020-04-19 North East and Yorkshire 88
## 546 2020-04-20 North East and Yorkshire 100
## 547 2020-04-21 North East and Yorkshire 76
## 548 2020-04-22 North East and Yorkshire 84
## 549 2020-04-23 North East and Yorkshire 63
## 550 2020-04-24 North East and Yorkshire 72
## 551 2020-04-25 North East and Yorkshire 69
## 552 2020-04-26 North East and Yorkshire 65
## 553 2020-04-27 North East and Yorkshire 65
## 554 2020-04-28 North East and Yorkshire 57
## 555 2020-04-29 North East and Yorkshire 69
## 556 2020-04-30 North East and Yorkshire 57
## 557 2020-05-01 North East and Yorkshire 64
## 558 2020-05-02 North East and Yorkshire 48
## 559 2020-05-03 North East and Yorkshire 40
## 560 2020-05-04 North East and Yorkshire 49
## 561 2020-05-05 North East and Yorkshire 40
## 562 2020-05-06 North East and Yorkshire 51
## 563 2020-05-07 North East and Yorkshire 45
## 564 2020-05-08 North East and Yorkshire 42
## 565 2020-05-09 North East and Yorkshire 44
## 566 2020-05-10 North East and Yorkshire 40
## 567 2020-05-11 North East and Yorkshire 29
## 568 2020-05-12 North East and Yorkshire 27
## 569 2020-05-13 North East and Yorkshire 28
## 570 2020-05-14 North East and Yorkshire 31
## 571 2020-05-15 North East and Yorkshire 32
## 572 2020-05-16 North East and Yorkshire 35
## 573 2020-05-17 North East and Yorkshire 26
## 574 2020-05-18 North East and Yorkshire 30
## 575 2020-05-19 North East and Yorkshire 27
## 576 2020-05-20 North East and Yorkshire 22
## 577 2020-05-21 North East and Yorkshire 33
## 578 2020-05-22 North East and Yorkshire 22
## 579 2020-05-23 North East and Yorkshire 18
## 580 2020-05-24 North East and Yorkshire 26
## 581 2020-05-25 North East and Yorkshire 21
## 582 2020-05-26 North East and Yorkshire 21
## 583 2020-05-27 North East and Yorkshire 22
## 584 2020-05-28 North East and Yorkshire 21
## 585 2020-05-29 North East and Yorkshire 25
## 586 2020-05-30 North East and Yorkshire 20
## 587 2020-05-31 North East and Yorkshire 20
## 588 2020-06-01 North East and Yorkshire 17
## 589 2020-06-02 North East and Yorkshire 23
## 590 2020-06-03 North East and Yorkshire 23
## 591 2020-06-04 North East and Yorkshire 17
## 592 2020-06-05 North East and Yorkshire 18
## 593 2020-06-06 North East and Yorkshire 21
## 594 2020-06-07 North East and Yorkshire 14
## 595 2020-06-08 North East and Yorkshire 11
## 596 2020-06-09 North East and Yorkshire 12
## 597 2020-06-10 North East and Yorkshire 19
## 598 2020-06-11 North East and Yorkshire 7
## 599 2020-06-12 North East and Yorkshire 9
## 600 2020-06-13 North East and Yorkshire 10
## 601 2020-06-14 North East and Yorkshire 11
## 602 2020-06-15 North East and Yorkshire 9
## 603 2020-06-16 North East and Yorkshire 10
## 604 2020-06-17 North East and Yorkshire 9
## 605 2020-06-18 North East and Yorkshire 11
## 606 2020-06-19 North East and Yorkshire 6
## 607 2020-06-20 North East and Yorkshire 5
## 608 2020-06-21 North East and Yorkshire 4
## 609 2020-06-22 North East and Yorkshire 7
## 610 2020-06-23 North East and Yorkshire 8
## 611 2020-06-24 North East and Yorkshire 10
## 612 2020-06-25 North East and Yorkshire 4
## 613 2020-06-26 North East and Yorkshire 7
## 614 2020-06-27 North East and Yorkshire 4
## 615 2020-06-28 North East and Yorkshire 5
## 616 2020-06-29 North East and Yorkshire 2
## 617 2020-06-30 North East and Yorkshire 7
## 618 2020-07-01 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 619 2020-07-02 North East and Yorkshire 4
## 620 2020-07-03 North East and Yorkshire 4
## 621 2020-07-04 North East and Yorkshire 4
## 622 2020-07-05 North East and Yorkshire 3
## 623 2020-07-06 North East and Yorkshire 2
## 624 2020-07-07 North East and Yorkshire 3
## 625 2020-07-08 North East and Yorkshire 3
## 626 2020-07-09 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 627 2020-07-10 North East and Yorkshire 3
## 628 2020-07-11 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 629 2020-07-12 North East and Yorkshire 4
## 630 2020-07-13 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 631 2020-07-14 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 632 2020-07-15 North East and Yorkshire 2
## 633 2020-07-16 North East and Yorkshire 3
## 634 2020-07-17 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 635 2020-07-18 North East and Yorkshire 2
## 636 2020-07-19 North East and Yorkshire 2
## 637 2020-07-20 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 638 2020-07-21 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 639 2020-07-22 North East and Yorkshire 6
## 640 2020-07-23 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 641 2020-07-24 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 642 2020-07-25 North East and Yorkshire 5
## 643 2020-07-26 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 644 2020-07-27 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 645 2020-07-28 North East and Yorkshire 2
## 646 2020-07-29 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 647 2020-07-30 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 648 2020-07-31 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 649 2020-08-01 North East and Yorkshire 3
## 650 2020-08-02 North East and Yorkshire 2
## 651 2020-08-03 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 652 2020-08-04 North East and Yorkshire 2
## 653 2020-08-05 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 654 2020-08-06 North East and Yorkshire 4
## 655 2020-08-07 North East and Yorkshire 0
## 656 2020-08-08 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 657 2020-08-09 North East and Yorkshire 2
## 658 2020-08-10 North East and Yorkshire 2
## 659 2020-08-11 North East and Yorkshire 2
## 660 2020-08-12 North East and Yorkshire 1
## 661 2020-03-01 North West 0
## 662 2020-03-02 North West 0
## 663 2020-03-03 North West 0
## 664 2020-03-04 North West 0
## 665 2020-03-05 North West 1
## 666 2020-03-06 North West 0
## 667 2020-03-07 North West 0
## 668 2020-03-08 North West 1
## 669 2020-03-09 North West 0
## 670 2020-03-10 North West 0
## 671 2020-03-11 North West 0
## 672 2020-03-12 North West 2
## 673 2020-03-13 North West 3
## 674 2020-03-14 North West 1
## 675 2020-03-15 North West 4
## 676 2020-03-16 North West 2
## 677 2020-03-17 North West 4
## 678 2020-03-18 North West 6
## 679 2020-03-19 North West 7
## 680 2020-03-20 North West 10
## 681 2020-03-21 North West 11
## 682 2020-03-22 North West 13
## 683 2020-03-23 North West 15
## 684 2020-03-24 North West 21
## 685 2020-03-25 North West 21
## 686 2020-03-26 North West 29
## 687 2020-03-27 North West 36
## 688 2020-03-28 North West 28
## 689 2020-03-29 North West 46
## 690 2020-03-30 North West 67
## 691 2020-03-31 North West 52
## 692 2020-04-01 North West 86
## 693 2020-04-02 North West 96
## 694 2020-04-03 North West 95
## 695 2020-04-04 North West 98
## 696 2020-04-05 North West 102
## 697 2020-04-06 North West 100
## 698 2020-04-07 North West 135
## 699 2020-04-08 North West 127
## 700 2020-04-09 North West 119
## 701 2020-04-10 North West 117
## 702 2020-04-11 North West 138
## 703 2020-04-12 North West 125
## 704 2020-04-13 North West 129
## 705 2020-04-14 North West 131
## 706 2020-04-15 North West 114
## 707 2020-04-16 North West 135
## 708 2020-04-17 North West 98
## 709 2020-04-18 North West 113
## 710 2020-04-19 North West 71
## 711 2020-04-20 North West 83
## 712 2020-04-21 North West 76
## 713 2020-04-22 North West 86
## 714 2020-04-23 North West 85
## 715 2020-04-24 North West 66
## 716 2020-04-25 North West 66
## 717 2020-04-26 North West 55
## 718 2020-04-27 North West 54
## 719 2020-04-28 North West 57
## 720 2020-04-29 North West 63
## 721 2020-04-30 North West 59
## 722 2020-05-01 North West 45
## 723 2020-05-02 North West 56
## 724 2020-05-03 North West 55
## 725 2020-05-04 North West 48
## 726 2020-05-05 North West 48
## 727 2020-05-06 North West 44
## 728 2020-05-07 North West 49
## 729 2020-05-08 North West 42
## 730 2020-05-09 North West 31
## 731 2020-05-10 North West 42
## 732 2020-05-11 North West 35
## 733 2020-05-12 North West 38
## 734 2020-05-13 North West 25
## 735 2020-05-14 North West 26
## 736 2020-05-15 North West 33
## 737 2020-05-16 North West 32
## 738 2020-05-17 North West 24
## 739 2020-05-18 North West 31
## 740 2020-05-19 North West 35
## 741 2020-05-20 North West 27
## 742 2020-05-21 North West 27
## 743 2020-05-22 North West 26
## 744 2020-05-23 North West 31
## 745 2020-05-24 North West 26
## 746 2020-05-25 North West 31
## 747 2020-05-26 North West 27
## 748 2020-05-27 North West 27
## 749 2020-05-28 North West 28
## 750 2020-05-29 North West 20
## 751 2020-05-30 North West 19
## 752 2020-05-31 North West 13
## 753 2020-06-01 North West 12
## 754 2020-06-02 North West 27
## 755 2020-06-03 North West 22
## 756 2020-06-04 North West 22
## 757 2020-06-05 North West 16
## 758 2020-06-06 North West 26
## 759 2020-06-07 North West 20
## 760 2020-06-08 North West 23
## 761 2020-06-09 North West 17
## 762 2020-06-10 North West 16
## 763 2020-06-11 North West 16
## 764 2020-06-12 North West 11
## 765 2020-06-13 North West 10
## 766 2020-06-14 North West 15
## 767 2020-06-15 North West 16
## 768 2020-06-16 North West 15
## 769 2020-06-17 North West 13
## 770 2020-06-18 North West 14
## 771 2020-06-19 North West 7
## 772 2020-06-20 North West 11
## 773 2020-06-21 North West 8
## 774 2020-06-22 North West 11
## 775 2020-06-23 North West 13
## 776 2020-06-24 North West 13
## 777 2020-06-25 North West 15
## 778 2020-06-26 North West 6
## 779 2020-06-27 North West 7
## 780 2020-06-28 North West 9
## 781 2020-06-29 North West 9
## 782 2020-06-30 North West 7
## 783 2020-07-01 North West 3
## 784 2020-07-02 North West 6
## 785 2020-07-03 North West 7
## 786 2020-07-04 North West 4
## 787 2020-07-05 North West 6
## 788 2020-07-06 North West 9
## 789 2020-07-07 North West 8
## 790 2020-07-08 North West 5
## 791 2020-07-09 North West 10
## 792 2020-07-10 North West 2
## 793 2020-07-11 North West 5
## 794 2020-07-12 North West 0
## 795 2020-07-13 North West 6
## 796 2020-07-14 North West 4
## 797 2020-07-15 North West 5
## 798 2020-07-16 North West 2
## 799 2020-07-17 North West 4
## 800 2020-07-18 North West 5
## 801 2020-07-19 North West 3
## 802 2020-07-20 North West 0
## 803 2020-07-21 North West 2
## 804 2020-07-22 North West 3
## 805 2020-07-23 North West 2
## 806 2020-07-24 North West 1
## 807 2020-07-25 North West 0
## 808 2020-07-26 North West 3
## 809 2020-07-27 North West 1
## 810 2020-07-28 North West 1
## 811 2020-07-29 North West 2
## 812 2020-07-30 North West 1
## 813 2020-07-31 North West 0
## 814 2020-08-01 North West 2
## 815 2020-08-02 North West 0
## 816 2020-08-03 North West 7
## 817 2020-08-04 North West 3
## 818 2020-08-05 North West 1
## 819 2020-08-06 North West 1
## 820 2020-08-07 North West 0
## 821 2020-08-08 North West 2
## 822 2020-08-09 North West 3
## 823 2020-08-10 North West 2
## 824 2020-08-11 North West 2
## 825 2020-08-12 North West 0
## 826 2020-03-01 South East 0
## 827 2020-03-02 South East 0
## 828 2020-03-03 South East 1
## 829 2020-03-04 South East 0
## 830 2020-03-05 South East 1
## 831 2020-03-06 South East 0
## 832 2020-03-07 South East 0
## 833 2020-03-08 South East 1
## 834 2020-03-09 South East 1
## 835 2020-03-10 South East 1
## 836 2020-03-11 South East 1
## 837 2020-03-12 South East 0
## 838 2020-03-13 South East 1
## 839 2020-03-14 South East 1
## 840 2020-03-15 South East 5
## 841 2020-03-16 South East 8
## 842 2020-03-17 South East 7
## 843 2020-03-18 South East 10
## 844 2020-03-19 South East 9
## 845 2020-03-20 South East 13
## 846 2020-03-21 South East 7
## 847 2020-03-22 South East 25
## 848 2020-03-23 South East 20
## 849 2020-03-24 South East 22
## 850 2020-03-25 South East 29
## 851 2020-03-26 South East 35
## 852 2020-03-27 South East 34
## 853 2020-03-28 South East 36
## 854 2020-03-29 South East 55
## 855 2020-03-30 South East 58
## 856 2020-03-31 South East 65
## 857 2020-04-01 South East 66
## 858 2020-04-02 South East 55
## 859 2020-04-03 South East 72
## 860 2020-04-04 South East 80
## 861 2020-04-05 South East 82
## 862 2020-04-06 South East 88
## 863 2020-04-07 South East 100
## 864 2020-04-08 South East 83
## 865 2020-04-09 South East 104
## 866 2020-04-10 South East 88
## 867 2020-04-11 South East 88
## 868 2020-04-12 South East 88
## 869 2020-04-13 South East 84
## 870 2020-04-14 South East 65
## 871 2020-04-15 South East 72
## 872 2020-04-16 South East 56
## 873 2020-04-17 South East 86
## 874 2020-04-18 South East 57
## 875 2020-04-19 South East 70
## 876 2020-04-20 South East 87
## 877 2020-04-21 South East 51
## 878 2020-04-22 South East 54
## 879 2020-04-23 South East 57
## 880 2020-04-24 South East 64
## 881 2020-04-25 South East 51
## 882 2020-04-26 South East 51
## 883 2020-04-27 South East 41
## 884 2020-04-28 South East 40
## 885 2020-04-29 South East 47
## 886 2020-04-30 South East 29
## 887 2020-05-01 South East 37
## 888 2020-05-02 South East 36
## 889 2020-05-03 South East 17
## 890 2020-05-04 South East 35
## 891 2020-05-05 South East 29
## 892 2020-05-06 South East 25
## 893 2020-05-07 South East 27
## 894 2020-05-08 South East 26
## 895 2020-05-09 South East 28
## 896 2020-05-10 South East 19
## 897 2020-05-11 South East 25
## 898 2020-05-12 South East 27
## 899 2020-05-13 South East 18
## 900 2020-05-14 South East 32
## 901 2020-05-15 South East 25
## 902 2020-05-16 South East 22
## 903 2020-05-17 South East 18
## 904 2020-05-18 South East 22
## 905 2020-05-19 South East 12
## 906 2020-05-20 South East 22
## 907 2020-05-21 South East 15
## 908 2020-05-22 South East 17
## 909 2020-05-23 South East 21
## 910 2020-05-24 South East 17
## 911 2020-05-25 South East 13
## 912 2020-05-26 South East 19
## 913 2020-05-27 South East 19
## 914 2020-05-28 South East 12
## 915 2020-05-29 South East 22
## 916 2020-05-30 South East 8
## 917 2020-05-31 South East 12
## 918 2020-06-01 South East 11
## 919 2020-06-02 South East 13
## 920 2020-06-03 South East 18
## 921 2020-06-04 South East 11
## 922 2020-06-05 South East 11
## 923 2020-06-06 South East 10
## 924 2020-06-07 South East 12
## 925 2020-06-08 South East 8
## 926 2020-06-09 South East 10
## 927 2020-06-10 South East 11
## 928 2020-06-11 South East 5
## 929 2020-06-12 South East 6
## 930 2020-06-13 South East 7
## 931 2020-06-14 South East 7
## 932 2020-06-15 South East 8
## 933 2020-06-16 South East 14
## 934 2020-06-17 South East 9
## 935 2020-06-18 South East 4
## 936 2020-06-19 South East 7
## 937 2020-06-20 South East 5
## 938 2020-06-21 South East 3
## 939 2020-06-22 South East 2
## 940 2020-06-23 South East 8
## 941 2020-06-24 South East 7
## 942 2020-06-25 South East 5
## 943 2020-06-26 South East 8
## 944 2020-06-27 South East 9
## 945 2020-06-28 South East 6
## 946 2020-06-29 South East 5
## 947 2020-06-30 South East 5
## 948 2020-07-01 South East 2
## 949 2020-07-02 South East 8
## 950 2020-07-03 South East 3
## 951 2020-07-04 South East 6
## 952 2020-07-05 South East 5
## 953 2020-07-06 South East 4
## 954 2020-07-07 South East 6
## 955 2020-07-08 South East 3
## 956 2020-07-09 South East 7
## 957 2020-07-10 South East 3
## 958 2020-07-11 South East 4
## 959 2020-07-12 South East 4
## 960 2020-07-13 South East 5
## 961 2020-07-14 South East 5
## 962 2020-07-15 South East 6
## 963 2020-07-16 South East 3
## 964 2020-07-17 South East 1
## 965 2020-07-18 South East 5
## 966 2020-07-19 South East 2
## 967 2020-07-20 South East 6
## 968 2020-07-21 South East 4
## 969 2020-07-22 South East 2
## 970 2020-07-23 South East 3
## 971 2020-07-24 South East 1
## 972 2020-07-25 South East 1
## 973 2020-07-26 South East 3
## 974 2020-07-27 South East 0
## 975 2020-07-28 South East 3
## 976 2020-07-29 South East 2
## 977 2020-07-30 South East 3
## 978 2020-07-31 South East 1
## 979 2020-08-01 South East 2
## 980 2020-08-02 South East 3
## 981 2020-08-03 South East 0
## 982 2020-08-04 South East 0
## 983 2020-08-05 South East 0
## 984 2020-08-06 South East 0
## 985 2020-08-07 South East 0
## 986 2020-08-08 South East 1
## 987 2020-08-09 South East 0
## 988 2020-08-10 South East 1
## 989 2020-08-11 South East 0
## 990 2020-08-12 South East 0
## 991 2020-03-01 South West 0
## 992 2020-03-02 South West 0
## 993 2020-03-03 South West 0
## 994 2020-03-04 South West 0
## 995 2020-03-05 South West 0
## 996 2020-03-06 South West 0
## 997 2020-03-07 South West 0
## 998 2020-03-08 South West 0
## 999 2020-03-09 South West 0
## 1000 2020-03-10 South West 0
## 1001 2020-03-11 South West 1
## 1002 2020-03-12 South West 0
## 1003 2020-03-13 South West 0
## 1004 2020-03-14 South West 1
## 1005 2020-03-15 South West 0
## 1006 2020-03-16 South West 0
## 1007 2020-03-17 South West 2
## 1008 2020-03-18 South West 2
## 1009 2020-03-19 South West 4
## 1010 2020-03-20 South West 3
## 1011 2020-03-21 South West 6
## 1012 2020-03-22 South West 7
## 1013 2020-03-23 South West 8
## 1014 2020-03-24 South West 7
## 1015 2020-03-25 South West 9
## 1016 2020-03-26 South West 11
## 1017 2020-03-27 South West 13
## 1018 2020-03-28 South West 21
## 1019 2020-03-29 South West 18
## 1020 2020-03-30 South West 23
## 1021 2020-03-31 South West 23
## 1022 2020-04-01 South West 21
## 1023 2020-04-02 South West 23
## 1024 2020-04-03 South West 30
## 1025 2020-04-04 South West 42
## 1026 2020-04-05 South West 32
## 1027 2020-04-06 South West 34
## 1028 2020-04-07 South West 39
## 1029 2020-04-08 South West 47
## 1030 2020-04-09 South West 24
## 1031 2020-04-10 South West 46
## 1032 2020-04-11 South West 43
## 1033 2020-04-12 South West 23
## 1034 2020-04-13 South West 27
## 1035 2020-04-14 South West 24
## 1036 2020-04-15 South West 32
## 1037 2020-04-16 South West 29
## 1038 2020-04-17 South West 33
## 1039 2020-04-18 South West 25
## 1040 2020-04-19 South West 31
## 1041 2020-04-20 South West 26
## 1042 2020-04-21 South West 26
## 1043 2020-04-22 South West 23
## 1044 2020-04-23 South West 17
## 1045 2020-04-24 South West 19
## 1046 2020-04-25 South West 15
## 1047 2020-04-26 South West 27
## 1048 2020-04-27 South West 13
## 1049 2020-04-28 South West 17
## 1050 2020-04-29 South West 15
## 1051 2020-04-30 South West 26
## 1052 2020-05-01 South West 6
## 1053 2020-05-02 South West 7
## 1054 2020-05-03 South West 10
## 1055 2020-05-04 South West 17
## 1056 2020-05-05 South West 14
## 1057 2020-05-06 South West 19
## 1058 2020-05-07 South West 16
## 1059 2020-05-08 South West 6
## 1060 2020-05-09 South West 11
## 1061 2020-05-10 South West 5
## 1062 2020-05-11 South West 8
## 1063 2020-05-12 South West 7
## 1064 2020-05-13 South West 7
## 1065 2020-05-14 South West 6
## 1066 2020-05-15 South West 4
## 1067 2020-05-16 South West 4
## 1068 2020-05-17 South West 6
## 1069 2020-05-18 South West 4
## 1070 2020-05-19 South West 6
## 1071 2020-05-20 South West 1
## 1072 2020-05-21 South West 9
## 1073 2020-05-22 South West 7
## 1074 2020-05-23 South West 6
## 1075 2020-05-24 South West 3
## 1076 2020-05-25 South West 8
## 1077 2020-05-26 South West 11
## 1078 2020-05-27 South West 5
## 1079 2020-05-28 South West 10
## 1080 2020-05-29 South West 7
## 1081 2020-05-30 South West 3
## 1082 2020-05-31 South West 2
## 1083 2020-06-01 South West 7
## 1084 2020-06-02 South West 2
## 1085 2020-06-03 South West 7
## 1086 2020-06-04 South West 2
## 1087 2020-06-05 South West 2
## 1088 2020-06-06 South West 1
## 1089 2020-06-07 South West 3
## 1090 2020-06-08 South West 3
## 1091 2020-06-09 South West 0
## 1092 2020-06-10 South West 1
## 1093 2020-06-11 South West 2
## 1094 2020-06-12 South West 2
## 1095 2020-06-13 South West 2
## 1096 2020-06-14 South West 0
## 1097 2020-06-15 South West 2
## 1098 2020-06-16 South West 2
## 1099 2020-06-17 South West 0
## 1100 2020-06-18 South West 0
## 1101 2020-06-19 South West 0
## 1102 2020-06-20 South West 2
## 1103 2020-06-21 South West 0
## 1104 2020-06-22 South West 1
## 1105 2020-06-23 South West 1
## 1106 2020-06-24 South West 1
## 1107 2020-06-25 South West 0
## 1108 2020-06-26 South West 3
## 1109 2020-06-27 South West 0
## 1110 2020-06-28 South West 0
## 1111 2020-06-29 South West 1
## 1112 2020-06-30 South West 0
## 1113 2020-07-01 South West 0
## 1114 2020-07-02 South West 0
## 1115 2020-07-03 South West 0
## 1116 2020-07-04 South West 0
## 1117 2020-07-05 South West 1
## 1118 2020-07-06 South West 0
## 1119 2020-07-07 South West 0
## 1120 2020-07-08 South West 2
## 1121 2020-07-09 South West 0
## 1122 2020-07-10 South West 1
## 1123 2020-07-11 South West 0
## 1124 2020-07-12 South West 0
## 1125 2020-07-13 South West 1
## 1126 2020-07-14 South West 0
## 1127 2020-07-15 South West 0
## 1128 2020-07-16 South West 0
## 1129 2020-07-17 South West 1
## 1130 2020-07-18 South West 0
## 1131 2020-07-19 South West 0
## 1132 2020-07-20 South West 0
## 1133 2020-07-21 South West 0
## 1134 2020-07-22 South West 0
## 1135 2020-07-23 South West 0
## 1136 2020-07-24 South West 0
## 1137 2020-07-25 South West 0
## 1138 2020-07-26 South West 0
## 1139 2020-07-27 South West 0
## 1140 2020-07-28 South West 0
## 1141 2020-07-29 South West 0
## 1142 2020-07-30 South West 1
## 1143 2020-07-31 South West 0
## 1144 2020-08-01 South West 0
## 1145 2020-08-02 South West 0
## 1146 2020-08-03 South West 0
## 1147 2020-08-04 South West 0
## 1148 2020-08-05 South West 0
## 1149 2020-08-06 South West 0
## 1150 2020-08-07 South West 0
## 1151 2020-08-08 South West 0
## 1152 2020-08-09 South West 0
## 1153 2020-08-10 South West 0
## 1154 2020-08-11 South West 0
## 1155 2020-08-12 South West 01.5 Completion date
We extract the completion date from the NHS Pathways file timestamp:
The completion date of the NHS Pathways data is Thursday 13 Aug 2020.
1.6 Auxiliary functions
These are functions which will be used further in the analyses.
Function to estimate the generalised R-squared as the proportion of deviance explained by a given model:
## Function to calculate R2 for Poisson model
## not adjusted for model complexity but all models have the same DF here
Rsq <- function(x) {
1 - (x$deviance / x$null.deviance)
}Function to extract growth rates per region as well as halving times, and the associated 95% confidence intervals:
## function to extract the coefficients, find the level of the intercept,
## reconstruct the values of r, get confidence intervals
get_r <- function(model) {
## extract coefficients and conf int
out <- data.frame(r = coef(model)) %>%
rownames_to_column("var") %>%
cbind(confint(model)) %>%
filter(!grepl("day_of_week", var)) %>%
filter(grepl("day", var)) %>%
rename(lower_95 = "2.5 %",
upper_95 = "97.5 %") %>%
mutate(var = sub("day:", "", var))
## reconstruct values: intercept + region-coefficient
for (i in 2:nrow(out)) {
out[i, -1] <- out[1, -1] + out[i, -1]
}
## find the name of the intercept, restore regions names
out <- out %>%
mutate(nhs_region = model$xlevels$nhs_region) %>%
select(nhs_region, everything(), -var)
## find halving times
halving <- log(0.5) / out[,-1] %>%
rename(halving_t = r,
halving_t_lower_95 = lower_95,
halving_t_upper_95 = upper_95)
## set halving times with exclusion intervals to NA
no_halving <- out$lower_95 < 0 & out$upper_95 > 0
halving[no_halving, ] <- NA_real_
## return all data
cbind(out, halving)
}Functions used in the correlation analysis between NHS Pathways reports and deaths:
## Function to calculate Pearson's correlation between deaths and lagged
## reports. Note that `pearson` can be replaced with `spearman` for rank
## correlation.
getcor <- function(x, ndx) {
return(cor(x$deaths[ndx],
x$note_lag[ndx],
use = "complete.obs",
method = "pearson"))
}
## Catch if sample size throws an error
getcor2 <- possibly(getcor, otherwise = NA)
getboot <- function(x) {
result <- boot::boot.ci(boot::boot(x, getcor2, R = 1000),
type = "bca")
return(data.frame(n = sum(!is.na(x$note_lag) & !is.na(x$deaths)),
r = result$t0,
r_low = result$bca[4],
r_hi = result$bca[5]))
}Function to classify the day of the week into weekend, Monday, and the rest:
## Fn to add day of week
day_of_week <- function(df) {
df %>%
dplyr::mutate(day_of_week = lubridate::wday(date, label = TRUE)) %>%
dplyr::mutate(day_of_week = dplyr::case_when(
day_of_week %in% c("Sat", "Sun") ~ "weekend",
day_of_week %in% c("Mon") ~ "monday",
!(day_of_week %in% c("Sat", "Sun", "Mon")) ~ "rest_of_week"
) %>%
factor(levels = c("rest_of_week", "monday", "weekend")))
}Custom color palettes, color scales, and vectors of colors:
2 Temporal trends in NHS Pathways reports
2.1 Outline
We look for temporal patterns in COVID-19 related 111/999 calls and 111 online reports. Analyses are broken down by NHS region. We also look for estimates of recent growth rate and associated doubling / halving time.
2.2 Reports by region over time
tab_date_region_all <- x %>%
filter(!is.na(nhs_region)) %>%
group_by(date, nhs_region) %>%
summarise(n = sum(count))
dth %>%
mutate(trusted = case_when(date_report < max(dth$date_report)-delay_max ~ "Y",
date_report >= max(dth$date_report)-delay_max ~ "N"),
value = "Deaths",
vline = max(dth$date_report)-delay_max-1,
lab = "Truncated for reporting delay",
lab_pos_x = vline + 10,
lab_pos_y = 150,
lab_col = "darkgrey") %>%
rename(date = date_report,
n = deaths) %>%
bind_rows(
mutate(tab_date_region_all, value = "Reports",
trusted = "Y",
vline = as.Date("2020-03-23"),
lab = "Start of UK lockdown",
lab_pos_x = vline - 8,
lab_pos_y = 30200,
lab_col = "black")
) %>%
mutate(value = factor(value, levels = c("Reports","Deaths"))) -> dths_reports
plot_dth_report <-
ggplot(dths_reports, aes(date, n, colour = nhs_region)) +
# Add main points and lines, coloured by region and fade out deaths for excluded period
geom_point(aes(alpha = trusted)) +
geom_line(alpha = 0.2) +
geom_smooth(method = "loess", span = .5, color = "black") +
scale_colour_manual("", values = pal) +
scale_alpha_manual(values = c(0.3,1)) +
guides(alpha = F) +
# Add vertical markers for important dates with labels - different for each facet
ggnewscale::new_scale_colour() +
geom_vline(aes(xintercept = vline, col = value), lty = "solid") +
geom_text(aes(x = lab_pos_x, y = lab_pos_y, label = lab, col = value), size = 3) +
scale_colour_manual("",values = c("black","darkgrey"), guide = F) +
# Facet by deaths and reports
facet_grid(rows = vars(value), scales = "free_y", switch = "y") +
# Other formatting
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",strip.placement = "outside") +
rotate_x +
labs(x = NULL,
y = NULL)
plot_dth_report
2.3 Reports by region by age over time
We plot the number of 111/999 calls and 111 online reports by age, and the proportion of 111/999 calls and 111 online reports by age. In the second graph, the vertical lines indicate the proportion of individuals residing in the corresponding NHS region who belong to the corresponding age group.
tab_date_region_age_all <- x %>%
filter(!is.na(nhs_region),
age != "missing") %>%
group_by(date, nhs_region, age) %>%
summarise(n = sum(count))
tab_date_region_age_all %>%
ggplot(aes(x = date, y = n, fill = age)) +
geom_col(position = "stack") +
scale_fill_manual(values = age.pal) +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
axis.text.x = element_text(angle = 90, hjust = 1)) +
guides(fill = guide_legend(title = "Age", ncol = 3)) +
labs(x = NULL,
y = "Total daily reports by age") +
facet_wrap(~ nhs_region, ncol = 4)
tab_date_region_age_all <- tab_date_region_age_all %>%
group_by(date, nhs_region) %>%
summarise(tot = sum(n)) %>%
left_join(tab_date_region_age_all, by = c("date", "nhs_region")) %>%
mutate(prop_n = n/tot)
tab_date_region_age_all %>%
ggplot(aes(x = date, y = prop_n, color = age)) +
scale_color_manual(values = age.pal) +
geom_line() +
geom_point() +
geom_hline(data = nhs_region_pop, aes(yintercept = value, color = variable)) +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
axis.text.x = element_text(angle = 90, hjust = 1)) +
guides(color = guide_legend(title = "Age", ncol = 3)) +
labs(x = NULL,
y = "Proportion of daily reports by age") +
facet_wrap(~ nhs_region, ncol = 4)
2.4 Moving window model
We fit quasi-Poisson GLMs for 14-day windows to get growth rates over time.
## set moving time window (1/2/3 weeks)
w <- 14
# create empty df
r_all_sliding <- NULL
## make data for model
x_model_all_moving <- x %>%
filter(!is.na(nhs_region)) %>%
group_by(date, nhs_region) %>%
summarise(n = sum(count))
unique_dates <- unique(x_model_all_moving$date)
for (i in 1:(length(unique_dates) - w)) {
date_i <- unique_dates[i]
date_i_max <- date_i + w
model_data <- x_model_all_moving %>%
filter(date >= date_i & date < date_i_max) %>%
mutate(day = as.integer(date - date_i)) %>%
day_of_week()
mod <- glm(n ~ day * nhs_region + day_of_week,
data = model_data,
family = 'quasipoisson')
# get growth rate
r <- get_r(mod)
r$w_min <- date_i
r$w_max <- date_i_max
# combine all estimates
r_all_sliding <- bind_rows(r_all_sliding, r)
}
#serial interval distribution
SI_param = epitrix::gamma_mucv2shapescale(4.7, 2.9/4.7)
SI_distribution <- distcrete::distcrete("gamma", interval = 1,
shape = SI_param$shape,
scale = SI_param$scale,
w = 0.5)
#convert growth rates r to R0
r_all_sliding <- r_all_sliding %>%
mutate(R = epitrix::r2R0(r, SI_distribution),
R_lower_95 = epitrix::r2R0(lower_95, SI_distribution),
R_upper_95 = epitrix::r2R0(upper_95, SI_distribution))We examine the evolution of the growth rate by region over time.
# plot
plot_growth <-
r_all_sliding %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = r)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = lower_95, ymax = upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 0, linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0.5,0.5, "cm")) +
guides(colour = guide_legend(title = "", override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "",
y = "Estimated daily growth rate (r)") +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal)From the growth rate, we derive R and examine its value through time.
# plot
plot_R <-
r_all_sliding %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = R)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = R_lower_95, ymax = R_upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 1, linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0.5,0.5, "cm")) +
guides(color = guide_legend(title = "", override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "",
y = "Estimated effective reproduction\nnumber (Re)") +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal)
R <- r_all_sliding %>%
mutate(lower_95 = R_lower_95,
upper_95 = R_upper_95,
value = R,
measure = "R",
reference = 1)
r_R <- r_all_sliding %>%
mutate(measure = "r",
value = r,
reference = 0) %>%
bind_rows(R)
r_R %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = value)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = lower_95, ymax = upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(aes(yintercept = reference), linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
rotate_x +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0,0, "cm"),
strip.background = element_blank(),
# strip.text.x = element_blank(),
strip.placement = "outside"
) +
guides(color = guide_legend(title = "",
override.aes = list(fill = NA)),
fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "", y = "") +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal) +
facet_grid(rows = vars(measure),
scales = "free_y",
switch = "y",
labeller = as_labeller(c(r = "Daily growth rate (r)",
R = "Effective reproduction\nnumber (Re)")))
2.5 Moving window model - stratified by age
We repeat the above analysis, where we fit quasi-Poisson GLMs for 14-day windows to get growth rates over time, but apply this to each age group separately (0-18, 19-69, 70-120 years old).
We first run the analysis for 0-18 years old.
## set moving time window (2 weeks)
w <- 14
# create empty df
r_all_sliding_0_18 <- NULL
## make data for model
x_model_all_moving_0_18 <- x %>%
filter(!is.na(nhs_region),
age == "0-18") %>%
group_by(date, nhs_region) %>%
summarise(n = sum(count))
unique_dates <- unique(x_model_all_moving_0_18$date)
for (i in 1:(length(unique_dates) - w)) {
date_i <- unique_dates[i]
date_i_max <- date_i + w
model_data <- x_model_all_moving_0_18 %>%
filter(date >= date_i & date < date_i_max) %>%
mutate(day = as.integer(date - date_i)) %>%
day_of_week()
mod <- glm(n ~ day * nhs_region + day_of_week,
data = model_data,
family = 'quasipoisson')
# get growth rate
r <- get_r(mod)
r$w_min <- date_i
r$w_max <- date_i_max
# combine all estimates
r_all_sliding_0_18 <- bind_rows(r_all_sliding_0_18, r)
}
#serial interval distribution
SI_param = epitrix::gamma_mucv2shapescale(4.7, 2.9/4.7)
SI_distribution <- distcrete::distcrete("gamma", interval = 1,
shape = SI_param$shape,
scale = SI_param$scale, w = 0.5)
#convert growth rates r to R0
r_all_sliding_0_18 <- r_all_sliding_0_18 %>%
mutate(R = epitrix::r2R0(r, SI_distribution),
R_lower_95 = epitrix::r2R0(lower_95, SI_distribution),
R_upper_95 = epitrix::r2R0(upper_95, SI_distribution))# plot
plot_growth <-
r_all_sliding_0_18 %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = r)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = lower_95, ymax = upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 0, linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0.5,0.5, "cm")) +
guides(colour = guide_legend(title = "",override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "",
y = "Estimated daily growth rate (r)"
) +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal)# plot
plot_R <-
r_all_sliding_0_18 %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = R)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = R_lower_95, ymax = R_upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 1, linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0.5,0.5, "cm")) +
guides(color = guide_legend(title = "", override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "",
y = "Estimated effective reproduction\nnumber (Re)"
) +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal)
R <- r_all_sliding_0_18 %>%
mutate(lower_95 = R_lower_95,
upper_95 = R_upper_95,
value = R,
measure = "R",
reference = 1)
r_R <- r_all_sliding_0_18 %>%
mutate(measure = "r",
value = r,
reference = 0) %>%
bind_rows(R)
fig2_3_0_18 <- r_R %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = value)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = lower_95, ymax = upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(aes(yintercept = reference), linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0,0, "cm"),
strip.background = element_blank(),
strip.placement = "outside"
) +
guides(color = guide_legend(title = "", override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "", y = "") +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal) +
facet_grid(rows = vars(measure),
scales = "free_y",
switch = "y",
labeller = as_labeller(c(r = "Daily growth rate (r)",
R = "Effective reproduction\nnumber (Re)")))Then, we run the analysis for 19-69 years old.
## set moving time window (2 weeks)
w <- 14
# create empty df
r_all_sliding_19_69 <- NULL
## make data for model
x_model_all_moving_19_69 <- x %>%
filter(!is.na(nhs_region),
age == "19-69") %>%
group_by(date, nhs_region) %>%
summarise(n = sum(count))
unique_dates <- unique(x_model_all_moving_19_69$date)
for (i in 1:(length(unique_dates) - w)) {
date_i <- unique_dates[i]
date_i_max <- date_i + w
model_data <- x_model_all_moving_19_69 %>%
filter(date >= date_i & date < date_i_max) %>%
mutate(day = as.integer(date - date_i)) %>%
day_of_week()
mod <- glm(n ~ day * nhs_region + day_of_week,
data = model_data,
family = 'quasipoisson')
# get growth rate
r <- get_r(mod)
r$w_min <- date_i
r$w_max <- date_i_max
# combine all estimates
r_all_sliding_19_69 <- bind_rows(r_all_sliding_19_69, r)
}
#serial interval distribution
SI_param = epitrix::gamma_mucv2shapescale(4.7, 2.9/4.7)
SI_distribution <- distcrete::distcrete("gamma", interval = 1,
shape = SI_param$shape,
scale = SI_param$scale, w = 0.5)
#convert growth rates r to R0
r_all_sliding_19_69 <- r_all_sliding_19_69 %>%
mutate(R = epitrix::r2R0(r, SI_distribution),
R_lower_95 = epitrix::r2R0(lower_95, SI_distribution),
R_upper_95 = epitrix::r2R0(upper_95, SI_distribution))# plot
plot_growth <-
r_all_sliding_19_69 %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = r)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = lower_95, ymax = upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 0, linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0.5,0.5, "cm")) +
guides(colour = guide_legend(title = "", override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "",
y = "Estimated daily growth rate (r)") +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal)# plot
plot_R <-
r_all_sliding_19_69 %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = R)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = R_lower_95, ymax = R_upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 1, linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0.5,0.5, "cm")) +
guides(color = guide_legend(title = "", override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "",
y = "Estimated effective reproduction\nnumber (Re)"
) +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal)
R <- r_all_sliding_19_69 %>%
mutate(lower_95 = R_lower_95,
upper_95 = R_upper_95,
value = R,
measure = "R",
reference = 1)
r_R <- r_all_sliding_19_69 %>%
mutate(measure = "r",
value = r,
reference = 0) %>%
bind_rows(R)
fig2_3_19_69 <- r_R %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = value)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = lower_95, ymax = upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(aes(yintercept = reference), linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0,0, "cm"),
strip.background = element_blank(),
strip.placement = "outside"
) +
guides(color = guide_legend(title = "", override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "", y = "") +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal) +
facet_grid(rows = vars(measure),
scales = "free_y",
switch = "y",
labeller = as_labeller(c(r = "Daily growth rate (r)",
R = "Effective reproduction\nnumber (Re)")))Finally, we run the analysis for 70-120 years old.
## set moving time window (2 weeks)
w <- 14
# create empty df
r_all_sliding_70_120 <- NULL
## make data for model
x_model_all_moving_70_120 <- x %>%
filter(!is.na(nhs_region),
age == "70-120") %>%
group_by(date, nhs_region) %>%
summarise(n = sum(count))
unique_dates <- unique(x_model_all_moving_70_120$date)
for (i in 1:(length(unique_dates) - w)) {
date_i <- unique_dates[i]
date_i_max <- date_i + w
model_data <- x_model_all_moving_70_120 %>%
filter(date >= date_i & date < date_i_max) %>%
mutate(day = as.integer(date - date_i)) %>%
day_of_week()
mod <- glm(n ~ day * nhs_region + day_of_week,
data = model_data,
family = 'quasipoisson')
# get growth rate
r <- get_r(mod)
r$w_min <- date_i
r$w_max <- date_i_max
# combine all estimates
r_all_sliding_70_120 <- bind_rows(r_all_sliding_70_120, r)
}
#serial interval distribution
SI_param = epitrix::gamma_mucv2shapescale(4.7, 2.9/4.7)
SI_distribution <- distcrete::distcrete("gamma", interval = 1,
shape = SI_param$shape,
scale = SI_param$scale, w = 0.5)
#convert growth rates r to R0
r_all_sliding_70_120 <- r_all_sliding_70_120 %>%
mutate(R = epitrix::r2R0(r, SI_distribution),
R_lower_95 = epitrix::r2R0(lower_95, SI_distribution),
R_upper_95 = epitrix::r2R0(upper_95, SI_distribution))# plot
plot_growth <-
r_all_sliding_70_120 %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = r)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = lower_95, ymax = upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 0, linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0.5,0.5, "cm")) +
guides(colour = guide_legend(title = "",override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "",
y = "Estimated daily growth rate (r)"
) +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal)# plot
plot_R <-
r_all_sliding_70_120 %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = R)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = R_lower_95, ymax = R_upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 1, linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0.5,0.5, "cm")) +
guides(color = guide_legend(title = "", override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "",
y = "Estimated effective reproduction\nnumber (Re)") +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal)
R <- r_all_sliding_70_120 %>%
mutate(lower_95 = R_lower_95,
upper_95 = R_upper_95,
value = R,
measure = "R",
reference = 1)
r_R <- r_all_sliding_70_120 %>%
mutate(measure = "r",
value = r,
reference = 0) %>%
bind_rows(R)
fig2_3_70_120 <- r_R %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = value)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = lower_95, ymax = upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(aes(yintercept = reference), linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0,0, "cm"),
strip.background = element_blank(),
strip.placement = "outside"
) +
guides(color = guide_legend(title = "", override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "", y = "") +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal) +
facet_grid(rows = vars(measure),
scales = "free_y",
switch = "y",
labeller = as_labeller(c(r = "Daily growth rate (r)",
R = "Effective reproduction\nnumber (Re)"))) We combine the estimated growth rates and effective reproduction numbers into a single figure.
ggpubr::ggarrange(fig2_3_0_18,
fig2_3_19_69,
fig2_3_70_120,
nrow = 3,
labels = "AUTO",
common.legend = TRUE,
legend = "bottom",
align = "hv") 
3 Comparison with deaths time series
3.1 Outline
We want to explore the correlation between NHS Pathways reports and deaths, and assess the potential for reports to be used as an early warning system for disease resurgence.
Death data are publically available. We truncate the time series to avoid bias from reporting delay - we assume a conservative delay of three weeks.
3.2 Lagged correlation
We calculate Pearson’s correlation coefficient between deaths and NHS Pathways notifications using different lags. Confidence intervals are obtained using bootstrap. Note that results were also confirmed using Spearman’s rank correlation.
First we join the NHS Pathways and death data, and aggregate over all England:
## truncate death data for reporting delay
trunc_date <- max(dth$date_report) - delay_max
dth_trunc <- dth %>%
rename(date = date_report) %>%
filter(date <= trunc_date)
## join with notification data
all_data <- x %>%
filter(!is.na(nhs_region)) %>%
group_by(date, nhs_region) %>%
summarise(count = sum(count, na.rm = T)) %>%
ungroup %>%
inner_join(dth_trunc,
by = c("date","nhs_region"))
all_tot <- all_data %>%
group_by(date) %>%
summarise(count = sum(count, na.rm = TRUE),
deaths = sum(deaths, na.rm = TRUE)) We calculate correlation with lagged NHS Pathways reports from 0 to 30 days behind deaths:
## Calculate all correlations + bootstrap CIs
lag_cor <- data.frame()
for (i in 0:30) {
## lag reports
summary <- all_tot %>%
mutate(note_lag = lag(count, i)) %>%
## calculate rank correlation and bootstrap CI
getboot(.) %>%
mutate(lag = i)
lag_cor <- bind_rows(lag_cor, summary)
}
cor_vs_lag <- ggplot(lag_cor, aes(lag, r)) +
theme_bw() +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = r_low, ymax = r_hi), alpha = 0.2) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 0, lty = "longdash") +
geom_point() +
geom_line() +
labs(x = "Lag between NHS pathways and death data (days)",
y = "Pearson's correlation") +
large_txt
cor_vs_lag
This analysis suggests that the best lag is 23 days. We then compare and plot the number of deaths reported against the number of NHS Pathways reports lagged by 23 days.
all_tot <- all_tot %>%
rename(date_death = date) %>%
mutate(note_lag = lag(count, lag_cor$lag[l_opt]),
note_lag_c = (note_lag - mean(note_lag, na.rm = T)),
date_note = lag(date_death,16))
lag_mod <- glm(deaths ~ note_lag, data = all_tot, family = "quasipoisson")
summary(lag_mod)
##
## Call:
## glm(formula = deaths ~ note_lag, family = "quasipoisson", data = all_tot)
##
## Deviance Residuals:
## Min 1Q Median 3Q Max
## -16.703 -6.193 -1.388 3.975 10.928
##
## Coefficients:
## Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept) 4.297e+00 7.559e-02 56.84 <2e-16 ***
## note_lag 1.700e-05 7.891e-07 21.55 <2e-16 ***
## ---
## Signif. codes: 0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
##
## (Dispersion parameter for quasipoisson family taken to be 37.84845)
##
## Null deviance: 19652.6 on 103 degrees of freedom
## Residual deviance: 4187.7 on 102 degrees of freedom
## (23 observations deleted due to missingness)
## AIC: NA
##
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 5
exp(coefficients(lag_mod))
## (Intercept) note_lag
## 73.452907 1.000017
exp(confint(lag_mod))
## 2.5 % 97.5 %
## (Intercept) 63.150697 84.940957
## note_lag 1.000015 1.000019
Rsq(lag_mod)
## [1] 0.7869138
mod_fit <- as.data.frame(predict(lag_mod, type = "link", se.fit = TRUE)[1:2])
all_tot_pred <-
all_tot %>%
filter(!is.na(note_lag)) %>%
mutate(pred = mod_fit$fit,
pred.se = mod_fit$se.fit,
low = exp(pred - 1.96*pred.se),
hi = exp(pred + 1.96*pred.se))
glm_fit <- all_tot_pred %>%
filter(!is.na(note_lag)) %>%
ggplot(aes(x = note_lag, y = deaths)) +
geom_point() +
geom_line(aes(y = exp(pred))) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = low, ymax = hi), alpha = 0.3, col = "grey") +
theme_bw() +
labs(y = "Daily number of\ndeaths reported",
x = "Daily number of NHS Pathways reports") +
large_txt
glm_fit
4 Supplementary figures
4.1 Serial interval distribution
This is a comparison of gamma versus lognormal distribution for the serial interval used to convert r to R in our analysis. Both distributions are parameterised with mean 4.7 and standard deviation 2.9.
SI_param <- epitrix::gamma_mucv2shapescale(4.7, 2.9/4.7)
SI_distribution <- distcrete::distcrete("gamma", interval = 1,
shape = SI_param$shape,
scale = SI_param$scale, w = 0.5)
SI_distribution2 <- distcrete::distcrete("lnorm", interval = 1,
meanlog = log(4.7),
sdlog = log(2.9), w = 0.5)
SI_dist1 <- data.frame(x = SI_distribution$r(1e5))
SI_dist1 <- count(SI_dist1, x) %>%
ggplot() +
geom_col(aes(x = x, y = n)) +
labs(x = "Serial interval (days)", y = "Frequency") +
scale_x_continuous(breaks = seq(0, 30, 5)) +
theme_bw()
SI_dist2 <- data.frame(x = SI_distribution2$r(1e5))
SI_dist2 <- count(SI_dist2, x) %>%
ggplot() +
geom_col(aes(x = x, y = n)) +
labs(x = "Serial interval (days)", y = "Frequency") +
scale_x_continuous(breaks = seq(0, 200, 20), limits = c(0, 200)) +
theme_bw()
ggpubr::ggarrange(SI_dist1,
SI_dist2,
nrow = 1,
labels = "AUTO") 
4.2 Sensitivity analysis - 7 or 21 days moving window
We reproduce the window analysis with either a 7 or 21 days window for sensitivity purposes.
First with the 7 days window:
## set moving time window (1/2/3 weeks)
w <- 7
# create empty df
r_all_sliding_7days <- NULL
## make data for model
x_model_all_moving <- x %>%
filter(!is.na(nhs_region)) %>%
group_by(date, nhs_region) %>%
summarise(n = sum(count))
unique_dates <- unique(x_model_all_moving$date)
for (i in 1:(length(unique_dates) - w)) {
date_i <- unique_dates[i]
date_i_max <- date_i + w
model_data <- x_model_all_moving %>%
filter(date >= date_i & date < date_i_max) %>%
mutate(day = as.integer(date - date_i)) %>%
day_of_week()
mod <- glm(n ~ day * nhs_region + day_of_week,
data = model_data,
family = 'quasipoisson')
# get growth rate
r <- get_r(mod)
r$w_min <- date_i
r$w_max <- date_i_max
# combine all estimates
r_all_sliding_7days <- bind_rows(r_all_sliding_7days, r)
}
#serial interval distribution
SI_param = epitrix::gamma_mucv2shapescale(4.7, 2.9/4.7)
SI_distribution <- distcrete::distcrete("gamma", interval = 1,
shape = SI_param$shape,
scale = SI_param$scale,
w = 0.5)
#convert growth rates r to R0
r_all_sliding_7days <- r_all_sliding_7days %>%
mutate(R = epitrix::r2R0(r, SI_distribution),
R_lower_95 = epitrix::r2R0(lower_95, SI_distribution),
R_upper_95 = epitrix::r2R0(upper_95, SI_distribution))# plot
plot_growth <-
r_all_sliding_7days %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = r)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = lower_95, ymax = upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 0, linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0.5,0.5, "cm")) +
guides(colour = guide_legend(title = "",override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "",
y = "Estimated daily growth rate (r)") +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal)plot_R <- r_all_sliding_7days %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = R)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = R_lower_95, ymax = R_upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 1, linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0.5,0.5, "cm")) +
guides(color = guide_legend(title = "", override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "",
y = "Estimated effective reproduction\nnumber (Re)") +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal)
R <- r_all_sliding_7days %>%
mutate(lower_95 = R_lower_95,
upper_95 = R_upper_95,
value = R,
measure = "R",
reference = 1)
r_R <- r_all_sliding_7days %>%
mutate(measure = "r",
value = r,
reference = 0) %>%
bind_rows(R)
r_R_7 <- r_R %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = value)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = lower_95, ymax = upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(aes(yintercept = reference), linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0,0, "cm"),
strip.background = element_blank(),
strip.placement = "outside"
) +
guides(color = guide_legend(title = "", override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "", y = "") +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal) +
facet_grid(rows = vars(measure),
scales = "free_y",
switch = "y",
labeller = as_labeller(c(r = "Daily growth rate (r)",
R = "Effective reproduction\nnumber (Re)")))Then with the 21 days window:
## set moving time window (1/2/3 weeks)
w <- 21
# create empty df
r_all_sliding_21days <- NULL
## make data for model
x_model_all_moving <- x %>%
filter(!is.na(nhs_region)) %>%
group_by(date, nhs_region) %>%
summarise(n = sum(count))
unique_dates <- unique(x_model_all_moving$date)
for (i in 1:(length(unique_dates) - w)) {
date_i <- unique_dates[i]
date_i_max <- date_i + w
model_data <- x_model_all_moving %>%
filter(date >= date_i & date < date_i_max) %>%
mutate(day = as.integer(date - date_i)) %>%
day_of_week()
mod <- glm(n ~ day * nhs_region + day_of_week,
data = model_data,
family = 'quasipoisson')
# get growth rate
r <- get_r(mod)
r$w_min <- date_i
r$w_max <- date_i_max
# combine all estimates
r_all_sliding_21days <- bind_rows(r_all_sliding_21days, r)
}
#serial interval distribution
SI_param = epitrix::gamma_mucv2shapescale(4.7, 2.9/4.7)
SI_distribution <- distcrete::distcrete("gamma", interval = 1,
shape = SI_param$shape,
scale = SI_param$scale,
w = 0.5)
#convert growth rates r to R0
r_all_sliding_21days <- r_all_sliding_21days %>%
mutate(R = epitrix::r2R0(r, SI_distribution),
R_lower_95 = epitrix::r2R0(lower_95, SI_distribution),
R_upper_95 = epitrix::r2R0(upper_95, SI_distribution))# plot
plot_growth <-
r_all_sliding_21days %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = r)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = lower_95, ymax = upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 0, linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0.5,0.5, "cm")) +
guides(colour = guide_legend(title = "",override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "",
y = "Estimated daily growth rate (r)") +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal)# plot
plot_R <-
r_all_sliding_21days %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = R)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = R_lower_95, ymax = R_upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 1, linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0.5,0.5, "cm")) +
guides(color = guide_legend(title = "", override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "",
y = "Estimated effective reproduction\nnumber (Re)") +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal)
R <- r_all_sliding_21days %>%
mutate(lower_95 = R_lower_95,
upper_95 = R_upper_95,
value = R,
measure = "R",
reference = 1)
r_R <- r_all_sliding_21days %>%
mutate(measure = "r",
value = r,
reference = 0) %>%
bind_rows(R)
r_R_21 <- r_R %>%
ggplot(aes(x = w_max, y = value)) +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = lower_95, ymax = upper_95, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.1) +
geom_line(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_point(aes(colour = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(aes(yintercept = reference), linetype = "dashed") +
theme_bw() +
scale_weeks +
theme(legend.position = "bottom",
plot.margin = margin(0.5,1,0,0, "cm"),
strip.background = element_blank(),
strip.placement = "outside"
) +
guides(color = guide_legend(title = "", override.aes = list(fill = NA)), fill = FALSE) +
labs(x = "", y = "") +
scale_colour_manual(values = pal) +
facet_grid(rows = vars(measure),
scales = "free_y",
switch = "y",
labeller = as_labeller(c(r = "Daily growth rate (r)",
R = "Effective reproduction\nnumber (Re)")))And we combine both outputs into a single plot:
ggpubr::ggarrange(r_R_7,
r_R_21,
nrow = 2,
labels = "AUTO",
common.legend = TRUE,
legend = "bottom") 
4.3 Correlation between NHS Pathways reports and deaths by NHS region
lag_cor_reg <- data.frame()
for (i in 0:30) {
summary <-
all_data %>%
group_by(nhs_region) %>%
mutate(note_lag = lag(count, i)) %>%
## calculate rank correlation and bootstrap CI for each region
group_modify(~getboot(.x)) %>%
mutate(lag = i)
lag_cor_reg <- bind_rows(lag_cor_reg, summary)
}
cor_vs_lag_reg <-
lag_cor_reg %>%
ggplot(aes(lag, r, col = nhs_region)) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 0, lty = "longdash") +
geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = r_low, ymax = r_hi, col = NULL, fill = nhs_region), alpha = 0.2) +
geom_point() +
geom_line() +
facet_wrap(~nhs_region) +
scale_color_manual(values = pal) +
scale_fill_manual(values = pal, guide = F) +
theme_bw() +
labs(x = "Lag between NHS pathways and death data (days)", y = "Pearson's correlation", col = "NHS region") +
theme(legend.position = "bottom") +
guides(color = guide_legend(override.aes = list(fill = NA)))
cor_vs_lag_reg
5 Export data
We save the tables created during our analysis:
if (!dir.exists("excel_tables")) {
dir.create("excel_tables")
}
## list all tables, and loop over export
tables_to_export <- c("r_all_sliding", "lag_cor")
for (e in tables_to_export) {
rio::export(get(e),
file.path("excel_tables",
paste0(e, ".xlsx")))
}
## also export result from regression on lagged data
rio::export(lag_mod, file.path("excel_tables", "lag_mod.rds"))6 System information
6.1 Outline
The following information documents the system on which the document was compiled.
6.2 System
This provides information on the operating system.
Sys.info()
## sysname
## "Darwin"
## release
## "19.6.0"
## version
## "Darwin Kernel Version 19.6.0: Sun Jul 5 00:43:10 PDT 2020; root:xnu-6153.141.1~9/RELEASE_X86_64"
## nodename
## "Mac-1597399783398.local"
## machine
## "x86_64"
## login
## "root"
## user
## "runner"
## effective_user
## "runner"6.3 R environment
This provides information on the version of R used:
6.4 R packages
This provides information on the packages used:
sessionInfo()
## R version 4.0.2 (2020-06-22)
## Platform: x86_64-apple-darwin17.0 (64-bit)
## Running under: macOS Catalina 10.15.6
##
## Matrix products: default
## BLAS: /Library/Frameworks/R.framework/Versions/4.0/Resources/lib/libRblas.dylib
## LAPACK: /Library/Frameworks/R.framework/Versions/4.0/Resources/lib/libRlapack.dylib
##
## locale:
## [1] en_US.UTF-8/en_US.UTF-8/en_US.UTF-8/C/en_US.UTF-8/en_US.UTF-8
##
## attached base packages:
## [1] stats graphics grDevices utils datasets methods base
##
## other attached packages:
## [1] ggnewscale_0.4.2 ggpubr_0.4.0 lubridate_1.7.9
## [4] chngpt_2020.5-21 cyphr_1.1.0 DT_0.15
## [7] kableExtra_1.1.0 janitor_2.0.1 remotes_2.2.0
## [10] projections_0.5.1 earlyR_0.0.1 epitrix_0.2.2
## [13] distcrete_1.0.3 incidence_1.7.2 rio_0.5.16
## [16] reshape2_1.4.4 rvest_0.3.6 xml2_1.3.2
## [19] linelist_0.0.40.9000 forcats_0.5.0 stringr_1.4.0
## [22] dplyr_1.0.1 purrr_0.3.4 readr_1.3.1
## [25] tidyr_1.1.1 tibble_3.0.3 ggplot2_3.3.2
## [28] tidyverse_1.3.0 here_0.1 reportfactory_0.0.5
##
## loaded via a namespace (and not attached):
## [1] nlme_3.1-148 fs_1.5.0 webshot_0.5.2 httr_1.4.2
## [5] rprojroot_1.3-2 tools_4.0.2 backports_1.1.8 utf8_1.1.4
## [9] R6_2.4.1 mgcv_1.8-31 DBI_1.1.0 colorspace_1.4-1
## [13] withr_2.2.0 gridExtra_2.3 tidyselect_1.1.0 sodium_1.1
## [17] curl_4.3 compiler_4.0.2 cli_2.0.2 labeling_0.3
## [21] matchmaker_0.1.1 scales_1.1.1 digest_0.6.25 foreign_0.8-80
## [25] rmarkdown_2.3 pkgconfig_2.0.3 htmltools_0.5.0 dbplyr_1.4.4
## [29] htmlwidgets_1.5.1 rlang_0.4.7 readxl_1.3.1 rstudioapi_0.11
## [33] farver_2.0.3 generics_0.0.2 jsonlite_1.7.0 crosstalk_1.1.0.1
## [37] car_3.0-9 zip_2.1.0 magrittr_1.5 kyotil_2019.11-22
## [41] Matrix_1.2-18 Rcpp_1.0.5 munsell_0.5.0 fansi_0.4.1
## [45] viridis_0.5.1 abind_1.4-5 lifecycle_0.2.0 stringi_1.4.6
## [49] yaml_2.2.1 carData_3.0-4 snakecase_0.11.0 MASS_7.3-51.6
## [53] plyr_1.8.6 grid_4.0.2 blob_1.2.1 crayon_1.3.4
## [57] lattice_0.20-41 cowplot_1.0.0 splines_4.0.2 haven_2.3.1
## [61] hms_0.5.3 knitr_1.29 pillar_1.4.6 boot_1.3-25
## [65] ggsignif_0.6.0 reprex_0.3.0 glue_1.4.1 evaluate_0.14
## [69] data.table_1.13.0 modelr_0.1.8 vctrs_0.3.2 selectr_0.4-2
## [73] cellranger_1.1.0 gtable_0.3.0 assertthat_0.2.1 xfun_0.16
## [77] openxlsx_4.1.5 broom_0.7.0 rstatix_0.6.0 survival_3.1-12
## [81] viridisLite_0.3.0 ellipsis_0.3.1